Millie's Cookies Reviews
Millie's Cookies has an overall rating of 4.2 based on 26 reviews. Customer feedback on Millie's Cookies is mixed: Millie's Cookies reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious cookie variety, great gift options, fast delivery, friendly customer service, which strongly appeal to cookie lovers, gift shoppers, busy professionals, families. However, Millie's Cookies is often criticized for its higher price point, limited dietary options, occasional delivery issues, inconsistent cookie freshness.
26 reviews
5 Stars
11
4 Stars
3
3 Stars
7
2 Stars
0
1 Star
0
How would you rate Millie's Cookies?
All Millie's Cookies Reviews (26)
natalie_Armstrong04
May 15, 2026
"Pretty much my perfect cookie"
These were exactly how I like my cookies, soft in the middle with just a little crisp on the outside. Like, the texture was totally spot on.
0
Reply
conniegoldwyn7474
May 08, 2026
"Really tasty cookies"
I got a box of the mixed cookies and they were so good. The chocolate chip one was my fave, soft in the middle and not dry at all. They’re sweet, but in a nice way, not that weird fake kind of taste. Had them with a cup of tea and they dissapeared way too fast. Deffo ordering again
0
Reply
WILLIAMS
April 25, 2026
"The box showed up nice and tidy…"
The box showed up nice and tidy, and all the cookies were safe inside!!! Nothing was broken or messy, which was a relief!!! Super happy with how it arrived!!!
0
Reply
FREEMAN
March 29, 2026
"Finally, allergen info that’s easy to find"
Thank you for making the allergen info so easy to find. It’s ridiculous that so many places make people dig around for something this important, and they really need to do better. This was simple, clear, and saved me a lot of stress.
0
Reply
NicoleCollins_53
March 20, 2026
"Delivered right on time"
I ordered cookies for a birthday and, to be fair, I was a little nervous about whether they’d arrive in time. But they showed up exactly when they were supposed to, with no need to chase anything up. The box was in good condition too, so credit where it’s due, the delivery side was really smooth and I was happy with it.
0
Reply
KatherineShealy_74
March 16, 2026
"Good cookies, service could be better"
I stopped in for some cookies, and they were tasty overall. I’d say the wait felt like maybe a little longer than it should’ve been, and the staff didn’t come across as super friendly. They seemed busy and kind of rushed me through the order. Not a bad visit by any means, but it probably could’ve been a nicer experience.
0
Reply
JeremyJones
March 07, 2026
"So many options"
There were so many cookies to choose from... I kind of didn’t know where to start. Loved having all that variety though...
0
Reply
hello_valerie212
March 02, 2026
"I ordered these cookies for a birthday gift…"
I ordered these cookies for a birthday gift and they were a hit. Picking what I wanted was really easy, which I appreciated because I was doing it kind of last minute, and the delivery showed up on time too. My friend said they looked really cute, and apparently they tasted fresh as well. I always struggle with presents sometimes, so this was a nice easy win. I’d definitely use them again when I’m stuck for an idea.
0
Reply
LucilleBasel_58
February 19, 2026
"Actually had everything I needed"
I was expecting at least one thing to be unavailable, but everything I wanted was in stock this time. No missing items, which was a nice surprise.
0
Reply
nicole_Brooks81
February 18, 2026
"Tasty cookies, but the wait was a bit much"
The cookies were genuinely good, so I can’t be too mad, but the line moved painfully slow. The whole experience had that “worth it, but only if you’re not in a rush” kind of vibe.
0
Reply
megan1996
February 12, 2026
"Fresh, soft cookies that I’d happily order again"
I ordered from Millie’s Cookies for a small birthday get-together, they were really lovely. They arrived tasting super fresh, soft in the middle, and not dry at all. They even had that nice just-baked smell when I opened them, which was a great surprise. The only small downside was that the delivery box had a bashed corner, but luckily the cookies themselves were completely fine. Overall, I’d say they’re definitely worth ordering again.
0
Reply
KING
February 02, 2026
"Cookie mix-up, but okay overall"
I got the wrong cookie and another one was missing, but the rest of the order was fine. Not a huge deal, just a little disappointing.
0
Reply
EdisonAnderson
February 01, 2026
"Felt impersonal"
The name looked a bit messy, and the whole thing made me feel more like a ticket number than an actual customer. It wasn’t a huge issue, but it did make the experience feel kind of careless.
0
Reply
hello_david084
January 11, 2026
"Worth money"
I think it was worth the money. I wasn’t expecting too much at first, but after using it for bit, I’m happy with what I got. Good quality and does what it should
0
Reply
john-Byers
January 04, 2026
"Cookies tasted good, but felt small"
The cookies tasted good and the delivery was fine, but they were smaller than I expected for the price. They weren’t bad at all, I just wish the portions felt a little more worth it. If they stay this size, I might end up ordering from somewhere else next time.
0
Reply
LeslieLucas
December 22, 2025
"I ordered cookies from milliescookies.com for my sister’s…"
I ordered cookies from milliescookies.com for my sister’s birthday and the whole process was really easy. The website was straightforward, I found what I wanted quickly, and checkout was nice and hassle-free. I got the confirmation email pretty much straight away too. No complaints at all, I’d definitely use them again.
0
Reply
hello_michael584
December 22, 2025
"Pretty Good Presentation Overall"
The presentation was good overall. To be fair, it was clear that some effort went into it, and most of the information was easy to follow. There might be a few areas that could be tightened up, but in general, I thought it was a solid presentation.
0
Reply
GARDUNO
December 16, 2025
"Decent Delivery"
Delivery was fine overall, just took a little longer than I expected haha. Not a big deal, but it was a bit slow tbh.
0
Reply
DYAS
December 13, 2025
"Cute Decorations, Good Icing"
I was kind of in a rush when I picked it up, but I did notice the decorations looked really cute. The icing was good too, so overall I was happy with it.
0
Reply
lesterharris0802
December 11, 2025
"Click and collect was easy enough"
Ordered some cookies for click and collect and they were ready when I got there, which was a relief because I really didn’t want to deal with any extra hassle. The staff were nice and everything went smoothly. Still had to make the effort to go pick them up, obviously, but it was painless enough and I’d use it again.
0
Reply
Have a question about Millie's Cookies?
Log in to ask your Millie's Cookies question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
